The advantages of supercritical water (SCW) as a reaction medium for upgrading oil sand bitumen were investigated through a comprehensive analysis of the output product, which includes gaseous products, middle distillate, distillation residue, and coke. Canadian oil sand bitumen mined by the steam assisted gravity drainage method was treated in an autoclave at 420-450 degrees C and 20-30 MPa for up to 120 min with three kinds of reaction media: SCW, high-pressure nitrogen, and supercritical toluene. The yields of gaseous products indicated that a very small amount of water was involved in the upgrading reaction. The analytical results of the middle distillate fractions were almost the same using water and nitrogen at 450 degrees C. The distillation residues produced in SCW had lower molecular weight distributions, lower H/C atomic ratios, higher aromaticities, and consequently more condensed structures compared to those produced in nitrogen. The coke produced using SCW also had lower H/C values and higher aromaticides. Judging from all the analytical results, the upgrading of bitumen by SCW reaction was primarily considered to be physical in nature. As a result, it is possible to highly disperse the heavy fractions by SCW. This dispersion effect of SCW led to intramolecular dehydrogenation of the heavier component and prevention of recombination reactions, and consequently gave the highest conversion. (C) 2010 Published by Elsevier B.V.