Atomistic grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations were performed in this work to investigate the role of open copper sites of Cu-BTC in affecting the separation of carbon monoxide from binary mixtures containing methane, nitrogen, or hydrogen. Mixtures containing 5%,50%, or 95% CO were examined. The simulations show that electrostatic interactions between the CO dipole and the partial charges on the metal-organic framework (MOF) atoms dominate the adsorption mechanism. The binary simulations show that Cu-BTC is quite selective for CO over hydrogen and nitrogen for all three mixture compositions at 298 K. The removal of CO from a 5% mixture with methane is slightly enhanced by the electrostatic interactions of CO with the copper sites. However, the pore space of Cu-BTC is large enough to accommodate both molecules at their pure-component loadings, and in general, Cu-BTC exhibits no significant selectivity for CO over methane for the equimolar and 95% mixtures. On the basis of the pure-component and low-concentration behavior of CO, the results indicate that MOFs with open metal sites have the potential for enhancing adsorption separations of molecules of differing polarities, but the pore size relative to the sorbate size will also play a significant role.