We have investigated the formation of 2-adamantanethiolate self-assembled monolayers on Au{III} and their displacement by n-dodecanethiol, using scanning tunneling microscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy. Well-ordered 2-adamantanethiolate monolayers undergo rapid and significant molecular exchange upon exposure to n-dodecanethiol solutions, but their structures and intermolecular interactions template the growth of n-dodecanethiolate domains. Annealing 2-adamantanethiolate monolayers at 78 degrees C decreases the density of vacancy islands, while increasing the overall order and the average domain sizes in the films. This results in slower displacement by n-dodecanethiol molecules, as compared to unannealed monolayers. The secondary sulfur position on the adamantyl cage influences the lattice structure and exchange of 2-adamantanethiolate monolayers by alkanethiols.