Activated sludge with sludge volume index (SVI)(30) of 77 ml g(-1) and SVI30 of 433 ml g(-1) was inoculated to start up reactors R1 and R2, respectively. In both RI and R2, cycle time of 1 h and the influent chemical oxygen demand (COD) concentrations of 1,000 mg l(-1) were employed. Initial settling time of 2 min resulted in the loss of a substantial amount of biomass as wash-out and high effluent COD concentrations within the first week of operation. This implied that there was no starvation phase in each cycle of R1 and R2 during the first week of operation. However, aerobic granules with a size above 400 mu m formed by day 7. Thus, it was concluded that starvation was not a prerequisite for the fori-nation of aerobic granules. When cycle time was 1 h, the instability of aerobic granules was observed. When cycle time was prolonged to 1.5 h and granular sludge of 200 ml was used to start up reactor R3, the reactor R3 reached steady state within 1 week. SVI, size, and the morphology of granular sludge in R3 remained stable during the 47-day operation, which indicated that prolonged starvation time had positive effects on the stability of aerobic granules.