The advancing contact angle (theta(adv)) of water on thin films (similar to 1 mu m) of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) with fluoroalkyl endgroups (6 kg/mol PEG with 10-carbon fluoroalkyl, denoted 6KC10) changes strongly with relative humidity (RH). Films of 6KC10 on silicon wafers pretreated with a fluorinated alkylsilane (TFOS) display theta(adv) increasing from 75 degrees at 12% RH to 95 degrees at 94% RH. The surprising transition to nonwetting character at high humidity is attributed to fluoroalkyl groups ordering at the air-hydrogel interface when they are liberated by dissolution of PEG crystallites above 85% RH. When water is withdrawn from a drop on 6KC10, the contact line does not recede. This extreme hysteresis is attributed to restructuring of the gel to bury the fluoroalkyl groups when in contact with water.