We here show that the iron-molybdenum (FeMo)-cofactor of the nitrogenase alpha-70(IIe) molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein variant accumulates a novel S = 1/2 state that can be trapped during the reduction of protons to H-2. H-1,H-2-ENDOR measurements disclose the presence of two protons/hydrides (H+/-) whose hyperfine tensors have been determined from two-dimensional field-frequency H-1 ENDOR plots. The two H+/- have large isotropic hyperfine couplings, A(iso) approximate to 23 MHz, which shows they are bound to the cofactor. The favored analysis for these plots indicates that the two H+/- have the same principal values, which indicates that they are chemically equivalent. The tensors are further related to each other by a permutation of the tensor components, which indicates an underlying symmetry of binding relative to the cofactor. At present, no model for the structure of the iron-molybdenum (FeMo)-cofactor in the S = 1/2 state trapped during the reduction of H+ can be shown unequivocally to satisfy all of the constraints generated by the ENDOR analysis. The data disfavors any model that involves protonation of sulfides, and thus suggests that the intermediate instead contains two chemically equivalent bound hydrides; it appears unlikely that these are terminal monohydrides.