The dehydrogenation of methanol on Rh(111), on a Rh(111)/V subsurface alloy and on Rh(111) with V islands has been studied with and without preadsorbed oxygen using a supersonic molecular beam and temperature programmed desorption. The reactivity is highest for the V islands surface without oxygen. But this surface is deactivated due to CO dissociation. The subsurface alloy is less reactive than the islands, but still more active than the Rh(111) surface. The reaction products are carbon monoxide and hydrogen only. With preadsorbed oxygen Rh(111) is the most active surface, but a strong dependence of the activity on the amount of preadsorbed oxygen is found for all three surfaces. The reaction products with preadsorbed oxygen are water, hydrogen, carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide. The reactions follow the same mechanism on all surfaces, but the activation energy of the individual reaction steps is different leading to significant changes in the thermal desorption spectra and in King and Wells-type experiments. (C) 2004 American Institute of Physics.