Sum-frequency spectroscopy has been used to investigate the behavior of self-assembled monolayers in a solid-solid contact. Various alkanethiol layers on gold were observed before, during, and after compression to 660 MPa against a sapphire counterface. Well-ordered layers that differ only in the length of their alkane tails (C-8 versus C-18) behave similarly. In contrast, defective and partly melted monolayers are more sensitive to stress than are their well-ordered analogues, and they are more prone to irreversible changes. In all cases, the intensity of methyl C-H stretching modes decreases with applied pressure, indicating a loss of net orientational order among the terminal methyl groups. The magnitude of this effect in well-ordered layers can be compared with the theoretical sensitivity of the resonant sum-frequency signal to molecular orientation. On these grounds, an increased population of terminal gauche conformers is identified as the disordering mechanism under pressure.