Pre-deforming polystyrene by rolling results in elimination of strain softening and induces ductile deformation behaviour in a subsequent tensile test. However, both yield stress and strain softening recover in time as a result of ageing, resulting in renewed brittle failure behaviour. The kinetics of this process is addressed in this paper. Although the process of recovery of yield stress and strain softening shows no molecular weight dependence, the time-scale of renewed brittle fracture after rejuvenation does. Any localisation of strain can only be stabilised if the molecular network can transfer sufficient load. For relatively low molecular-weight polystyrene, the load bearing capacity is already exceeded at short ageing times, whereas for higher molecular-weight grades this takes longer. Since the creep compliance and shift-rate of mechanically rejuvenated polystyrene shows a pronounced increase as compared to thermally rejuvenated polystyrene, the segmental mobility in the mechanically rejuvenated samples has increased, despite a lower free volume. This indicates that a new explanation for ageing should be postulated, which is discussed.