In this manuscript, we use classical molecular dynamics simulation to explore the origin of specific cation effects on the rates of bulk-phase aqueous electron transfer (ET) reactions. We consider 0.6 M solutions of Cl- and a series of different cations: Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+, and Cs+. We evaluate the collective electrostatic fluctuations that drive Marcus-like ET and find that they are essentially unaffected by changes in the cationic species. This finding implies that the structure making/breaking properties of various cations do not exert a significant influence on bulk-phase ET reactions. We evaluate the role of ion pairing in these specific cation effects and find, unsurprisingly, that model redox anions that are more highly charged tend to pair more effectively with spectator cations than their monovalent counterparts. We demonstrate that this ion pairing significantly affects local electrostatic fluctuations for the anionic redox species and thus conclude that ion pairing is one of the likely sources of rate-dependent cation effects in aqueous ET reactions.