The physical, hydrological, and physico-chemical properties of horticultural substrates are influenced by particle shape and size. Sieve analysis is the predominate method utilized to characterize the particle size distribution of horticultural substrates. However, the effect of particle length on sieve analysis results have only been speculated. Laser cut particles with eight different length to width (L:W) ratios were sorted by sieves for agitation times ranging from 1 min to 5 min. To quantify the effect of L:W ratio and agitation time, the means (mid-point) and standard deviations of particle distributions were compared. Particles with a 1:1 L:W ratio were the most accurately sorted particles, containing midpoints most similar to true sieve size. As particle length increased, distribution midpoints and standard deviation increased. Elongated particles, 2:1 L:W ratio and greater, may cause the particle size distribution to skew positively. Increasing agitation time influences the probability of a particle and open sieve aperture converging in an orientation which allows it passage and can improve sieve accuracy and precision. By improving the consistency of sieving protocols, the accuracy of sieve analysis could potentially be improved. However, alternative instruments should be evaluated to improve the characterization of horticultural substrates. If, in the future, the characteristics of elongated or complex-shaped particles are desired, it may prove more beneficial to refine engineering practices than rely on sieving to precisely sort and isolate them. (C) 2019 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).