Characterizing the hydrogen bond structure and dynamics at surfactant interfaces is essential for understanding how microscopic interactions translate to bulk microemulsion properties. Heterogeneous blends containing tens or hundreds of surfactants are common in the industry, but the most fundamental studies have been carried out on micelles composed of a single surfactant species. Therefore, the effect of surfactant heterogeneity on the interfacial structure and dynamics remains poorly understood. Here, we use ultrafast two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to characterize sub-picosecond solvation dynamics as a function of the surfactant composition in similar to 120 nm water-in-oil reverse micelles. We probe the ester carbonyl vibrations of nonionic sorbitan surfactants, which are located precisely at the interface between the polar and nonpolar regions, and as such, report on the interfacial water dynamics. We show a 7% increase in hydrogen bond populations together with a 37% slowdown of interfacial hydrogen bond dynamics in heterogeneous mixtures containing hundreds of species, compared to more uniform compositions. Simulations, which are in semiquantitative agreement with experiments, indicate that structural diversity leads to decreased packing efficiency, which in turn drives water further into the otherwise hydrophobic region. Interestingly, this increase in hydration is accompanied by a slowdown of dynamics, indicating that water molecules solvating surfactants are conformationally constrained. These studies demonstrate that the composition and heterogeneity are key factors in determining interfacial properties.