In nature, cyclic dipeptide prenyltransferases catalyze regioselective Friedel-Crafts alkylations of tryptophan-containing cyclic dipeptides. This enzyme class, belonging to the dimethylallyl tryptophan synthase superfamily, is known to be flexible toward aromatic prenyl acceptors, while mostly retaining its typical regioselectivity. Ardeemin fumiquinazoline (FQ) (1), a tryptophan-containing cyclic tripeptide derivative, is assembled in Aspergillus fischeri by the non-ribosomal peptide synthetase ArdA and modified by the prenyltransferase ArdB, leading to the pharmaceutically active hexacyclic ardeemin. Therefore, 1 and its enantiomer ent-ardeemin FQ (2) constitute potential substrates for aromatic prenyltransferases. In this study, we investigated the acceptance of both enantiomers by two cyclic dipeptide C2-prenyltransferases BrePT and FtmPT1 and three C3-prenyltransferases CdpNPT, CdpC3PT, and AnaPT. LC-MS analysis of the incubation mixtures and NMR analysis of the isolated products revealed that the stereochemistry at C11 and C14 in 1 and 2 has a strong influence on their acceptance by these enzymes and the regioselectivity of the prenylation reactions. 1 was very well accepted by BrePT, FtmPT1, and CdpNPT, with C2- or C3-prenylated derivatives as predominant products, which fills the prenylation gaps by tryptophan prenyltransferases reported in a previous study. 2 was a poor substrate for all the enzymes and converted with low regioselectivity and mainly prenylated at C6 and C7 of the indole moiety.