Chemical Engineering Research & Design, Vol.136, 886-899, 2018
Inter-compartment interaction in multi-impeller mixing. Part II. Experiments, sliding mesh and large Eddy simulations
Steady state multiple reference frame-RANS (MRF-RANS) simulations frequently show strong over-predictions of the mixing time in single-phase, multi-impeller mixing tanks, which is sometimes patched by ad hoc tuning of the turbulent Schmidt-number. In Part I of this work, we experimentally revealed the presence of macro-instabilities in the region between the impellers, as well as a peak in the turbulent kinetic energy in the region where the flow from the individual impellers converges. The MRF-RANS method was found unable to capture both. In this second paper, we show that the sliding-mesh BANS (SM-RANS) approach does capture the effect of macro-instabilities, while still underestimating the turbulent kinetic energy. Consequently, the SM-RANS method mildly over-estimates the mixing time, while being less sensitive to the exact mesh geometry. Large eddy simulations with the dynamic Smagorinsky model reasonably capture the kinetic energy contained in macro instabilities, and properly assess the turbulent kinetic energy in the region between the impellers, even for crude meshes. Consequently, the mixing time is reasonably assessed, and even under-predicted at the crudest meshes. However, the turbulent kinetic energy and energy dissipation in the impeller discharge stream are poorly assessed by the dynamic Smagorinsky model. (C) 2018 Institution of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.