Substantial research effort has been spent on the development of advanced compression ignition (ACI) engine combustion strategies over the past decades, including homogeneous charge compression ignition (HCCI), reactivity controlled compression ignition (RCCI), and gasoline direct-injection compression-ignition (GDCI), etc. The behavior of gasoline-type fuels under compression ignition conditions has subsequently attracted extensive experimental and kinetic modeling interest. On the other hand, towards the development of future transportation fuels and engines, the evaluation of general fuel properties, instead of endless testing of specific fuels, should be the future research focus. In this study, the individual roles of the research and motor octane numbers (i.e., RON and MON) and fuel sensitivity (S) in characterizing the ignition performance of gasoline surrogates have been systematically investigated under a typical ACI engine condition using well-validated surrogate and kinetic models. The crank angle corresponding to 50% total heat release (CA50) was utilized as an indicator of the overall fuel reactivity, and iso-contours of CA50 were mapped out in the full engine operating domain characterized by the temperature and pressure at intake valve closing (IVC). By comparing the ignition performance of toluene primary reference fuel blends (TPRF) with the same RON, MON or S values, the distinctive effects and dominant ACI operating conditions of these fuel properties are clearly demonstrated. The role of equivalence ratio is also discussed by comparing the intrinsic stoichiometric condition of the standard octane rating tests and the lean mixture conditions required by ACI operation. The results show that octane sensitivity manifests itself in the high pressure low temperature operating regime for fuels with identical RON or MON, through different low temperature reactivities and heat release rates, while in low pressure high temperature conditions, combustion phasing is less sensitive to all fuel properties, including RON, MON and S. TPRFs with the same sensitivity show the largest variation of CA50 in the intermediate operating conditions, where the thermodynamic traces pass primarily through the ignition delay regime characterized by negative-temperature coefficient (NTC) behavior. Finally, by comparing the combustion phasing of five different gasoline surrogates with nearly identical RON and MON, potential compositional effects for gasoline fuels under ACI condition are further discussed via kinetic modeling. This study also demonstrates that the controlling fuel properties of gasoline-like fuels depend on ACI operating conditions (pressure and temperature trajectory), which should be carefully considered when constructing fuel metrics and comparing experimental results of ACI engines. (C) 2018 The Combustion Institute. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.