Electrocatalytic energy conversion with molecular f-element catalysts is still in an early phase of its development. We here report detailed electrochemical investigations on the recently reported trivalent lanthanide coordination complexes [(((ArO)-Ar-Ad,me)(3)mes)Ln] (1-Ln), with Ln = La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Gd, Dy, Er, and Yb, which were now found to perform as active electrocatalysts for the reduction of water to dihydrogen. Reactivity studies involving complexes 1-Ln and the Ln(II) analogues [K(2.2.2-crypt)]-[(((ArO)-Ar-Ad,Me)(3)mes)Ln] (2-Ln) suggest a reaction mechanism that differs significantly from the reaction pathway found for the corresponding uranium catalyst [(((ArO)-Ar-Ad,Me)(3)mes)U] (1-U). While complexes 1-Ln activate water via a radical pathway, only upon a 1 e(-) reduction to yield the reduced species 2-Ln, the 5f analogue 1-U directly reduces H2O via a 2 e(-) pathway. The electrocatalytic H2O reduction by complexes 1-Ln is initiated by the respective Ln(III)/Ln(II) redox couples, which gradually turn to more positive values across the Ln series. This correlation has been exploited to tune the catalytic overpotential of water reduction by choice of the lanthanide ion. Kinetic studies of the 1-Ln series were performed to elucidate correlations between overpotential and turnover frequencies of the 4f-based electrocatalysts.