Many approaches to the self-assembly of interesting microstructures rely on particles with engineered shapes. We create dimpled solid particles by molding oil droplets in the interstices of a close-packed colloidal crystal and polymerizing them in situ, resulting in particles containing multiple spherical dimples arranged with various polyhedral symmetries. Monodisperse micrometer-sized droplets of 3-methacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane (TPM) are mixed with an excess of polystyrene (PS) microspheres (2.58 mu m) and allowed to sediment, forming colloidal crystals with TPM droplets inside their interstitial sites. When these crystals are compressed by partial drying, the trapped droplets wet the multiple microspheres surrounding them, forming a three-dimensional capillary bridge with the symmetry of the interstitial spaces, and then mild heating triggers polymerization in situ. Depending on the initial particle volume fraction and extent of drying, a high yield of dimpled particles having different symmetries including tetrahedra obtained. The fractional yield of different shapes varies with the size ratio of the TPM droplets and the PS microspheres forming the template lattice. Sedimentation velocity fractionation methods are effective for enrichment of specific symmetries but not complete purification. Our approach for forming polyhedral particles should be readily scalable to larger samples and smaller sized particles if desired.