Manganese oxides are a highly promising class of water-oxidation catalysts (WOCs), but the optimal MnOx formulation or polymorph is not clear from previous reports in the literature. A complication not limited to MnOx-based WOCs is that such catalysts are routinely evaluated by different methods, ranging from the use of a chemical oxidant such as Ce4+, photoactive mediators such as [Ru(bpy)(3)](2+), or electrochemical techniques. Here, we report a systematic study of nine crystalline MnOx materials as WOCs and show that the identity of the "best" catalyst changes, depending on the oxidation method used to probe the catalytic activity.